juerschue
06-10-2006, 07:30
In dem FMA Forum bin ich über einen interessanten Text über die Sichtweise, wie sich Stile entwickeln, wer der GM dieser Stile ist (ein Vergleich von Familienstilen, z.B. Karate, Gungfu Stile) und FMA Stilen gestolpert. Fande ich sehr interessant zu lesen und deshalb die Erwähnung hier. Nachstehend ein kurzer Ausszug:
Hier ein kurzer Ausszug:
"Martial Tradition - by "Knife" Sotelo"
.......
"Arnis is Tribal, not Familial
What do I mean by "impersonal?". The unit of ancient Filipino society is the barangay. A barangay is composed of several families which were not always related to one another. The number of dedicated warriors in a barangay was probably small. So every able-bodied man had to be able to defend the barangay. Thus arnis masters would teach any able-bodied man in the barangay regardless of the man's family.
In contrast, ancient Chinese and Japanese masters considered their martial arts as family heirlooms, to be used to defend the family of to enhance its prestige. So they confined - or tried to confine - their instruction to members of their clan. For example: Formerly only members of the Ch'en family could learn Tai Chi Chuan until Yang Lu-ch'an broke the monopoly. Only the Takeda family and their retainers could learn Aiki-jutsu. At present, even the Kano family tries to keep control of judo even though instruction is not confined to the Kano family and is open to any one.
In those styles, the titles of student, master, grandmaster, great grandmaster, and so on reflect those of the family, son, father, grandfather, great grandfather, etc. The master becomes the second father who can interfere in the most intimate details of the life of the student to an extent unknown to the arnisador.
.......
Im FMA Forum (www.fmaforum.org) wurde Arnis Bumaril in Verbindung mit okkulten Pratiken diskuiert. Nur der Vollständigkeit halber. Hier auch ein Auszug:
"The Institute of Arnis Bumaril is a legal institute for the study of Arnis Bumaril highly supported by the Independent Martial Arts Federation (IMF) under Rev. Marvin "Knife" Sotelo a satanic priest of the East Los Angeles Chapel of Satan..."
Gruss
Juerschue
Hier ein kurzer Ausszug:
"Martial Tradition - by "Knife" Sotelo"
.......
"Arnis is Tribal, not Familial
What do I mean by "impersonal?". The unit of ancient Filipino society is the barangay. A barangay is composed of several families which were not always related to one another. The number of dedicated warriors in a barangay was probably small. So every able-bodied man had to be able to defend the barangay. Thus arnis masters would teach any able-bodied man in the barangay regardless of the man's family.
In contrast, ancient Chinese and Japanese masters considered their martial arts as family heirlooms, to be used to defend the family of to enhance its prestige. So they confined - or tried to confine - their instruction to members of their clan. For example: Formerly only members of the Ch'en family could learn Tai Chi Chuan until Yang Lu-ch'an broke the monopoly. Only the Takeda family and their retainers could learn Aiki-jutsu. At present, even the Kano family tries to keep control of judo even though instruction is not confined to the Kano family and is open to any one.
In those styles, the titles of student, master, grandmaster, great grandmaster, and so on reflect those of the family, son, father, grandfather, great grandfather, etc. The master becomes the second father who can interfere in the most intimate details of the life of the student to an extent unknown to the arnisador.
.......
Im FMA Forum (www.fmaforum.org) wurde Arnis Bumaril in Verbindung mit okkulten Pratiken diskuiert. Nur der Vollständigkeit halber. Hier auch ein Auszug:
"The Institute of Arnis Bumaril is a legal institute for the study of Arnis Bumaril highly supported by the Independent Martial Arts Federation (IMF) under Rev. Marvin "Knife" Sotelo a satanic priest of the East Los Angeles Chapel of Satan..."
Gruss
Juerschue